PFM Board
The Performance Dimensions in Budget => The design and use of PEFA and other assessments => Topic started by: Napodano on November 19, 2026, 10:44:05 GMT
-
It is being said that you get ten people in a room discussing AI and you would end up with 10 different opinions and solutions. It is about time that we start the discussion of AI applied to PFM.
My approach, as for all other topics, is practical, based on my own experience.
Lets’ start with PEFA assessment and the recent introduction of an AI assistant on the secretariat website, ‘AskPEFA AI’, the blue bubble at the bottom right of the screen. I am strong believer of a staged reform process in PFM at country level. The idea to ask the PEFA internal AI to look at the analysis of past PEFA assessments in a country was appealing to me with a forward-looking approach.
I chose Tajikistan because I worked there in the past three years and I have a fresh, deep knowledge of the PFM reform in the country.
I asked the following question:
- ‘which key PFM issues would you highlight in a frank and open policy dialogue between the donors and the Tajik Government?’
The initial reply was later lame, resulting in a kind of bureaucratic summary of past assessments. I scolded the AI agent pointing to the ‘frank and open’ aspect of the intended dialogue and the second reply was:
‘In a frank and open policy dialogue between donors and the Tajik Government, it would be important to highlight the following key PFM issues:
1. Strengthening Budget Planning and Execution : Emphasize the need for a more robust medium-term budget framework and program budgeting to improve fiscal discipline and strategic allocation of resources.
2. Enhancing Transparency and Accountability : Discuss the importance of increasing public access to fiscal information and improving the transparency of budget processes to build trust and accountability.
3. Improving Internal Controls and Audit : Address the need to strengthen internal controls and the effectiveness of internal audits to ensure better financial management and reduce the risk of mismanagement.
4. Reforming Procurement Practices : Highlight the necessity of improving procurement systems to ensure competition, value for money, and compliance with international standards.
5. Enhancing External Audit and Oversight : Stress the importance of improving the quality and timeliness of financial statements and strengthening the role of external audits in providing independent oversight.
6. Building Institutional Capacity : Discuss the need for capacity building within government institutions to ensure the sustainability of PFM reforms and the retention of skilled personnel.
7. Fostering Political Commitment : Emphasize the importance of political will and commitment to drive and sustain PFM reforms, ensuring that they are prioritized and adequately resourced.’
The reply above is interesting for a country PFM insider who can deeply read into each point addressed and judge selectively where progress in the reform is trailing behind.
Now let’s come to the forward-looking approach that could be appied for future assessments not only for PEFA but also for EU Budget Support compliance missions of the PFM general condition, for example (using their past compliance mission reports).
It would be interesting to add to the standard high-level assessment a drill-down analysis on a single topic resulting from the AI consultation, on a rolling basis. In the case of Tajikistan, with hindsight I would choose the topics 6 and 7 for the drill down to be framed as ‘review of institutions to champion MTEF through stronger institutional collaboration and networking’. That means in Tajikistan a review of MTEF integration process among MOF, MoE and the Parliamentary Budget Committee.
What is your take on the above?
What is your experience in using AI for PFM reform assessments?